Cannot sort playlist tracks by 'Date Added' (ref#JY0XRX)

Hi! What’s not quite right with Roon?

· None of the above quite fits

None of the above quite fits

· None of these quite match

Tell us what's going on

· Hello, I have an issue. In the TRACKS section, I can see the "Date Added" column and sort tracks based on the date they were added. However, within a playlist, the "Date Added" column does not show any dates, which means I cannot sort the tracks by the date they were added—either to the TRACKS section or to the specific playlist. Is it possible to sort tracks by "Date Added" within a playlist as well, or am I doing something wrong? If this feature is not available, please consider adding it. Thank you. Best regards.

Tell us about your home network

· .

Hey @salandin,

Thanks for writing in! There’s an easy fix for you:

  1. Navigate to the playlist
  2. Click the cogwheel in the far right corner of the playlist
  3. Enable ‘Date Added’ from the list

Thats it! You can now sort by date added. Happy listening!

Hi Benjamin, thank you for your response. I likely didn’t explain myself clearly. I had already tried what you suggested—enabling the “DATE ​​ADDED” column—but the issue is that when I’m inside a playlist, no dates appear in that column, which means I cannot sort the tracks by “DATE ​​ADDED.” Conversely, when I’m in the “TRACKS” section, the dates do appear in the “DATE ​​ADDED” column, and I am able to sort them. I would like to be able to sort tracks by “DATE ​​ADDED” (whether that refers to the date added to the “TRACKS” library or the date added to a specific playlist) even when viewing a playlist.
I’ve attached two screenshots to illustrate what I mean (one for the Tracks section and one for the Playlist section).
Additionally, I think it would be useful to be able to rearrange the columns—for instance, moving them further to the left or right according to one’s own preferences.
Thanks again, and I look forward to hearing from you.
Best regards.

Hi @salandin,

I’m afraid you’ll need to explain this issue in a little more detail, because your screenshot seems to indicate that you’ve 1) toggled Date Added as a column to appear in the Playlist view and 2) are applying an active sort by that field.

Can you perhaps upload a short screen capture video demonstrating the failure?

Hover over the Date Added field. You should see Sort buttons appear automatically. One press will sort ascending; a second press will change to descending sort.

Date Added, as a value field, records the import date of the file to your Roon library. It doesn’t flexibly also refer to when you added the track to a Playlist. That’s an additional level of data topology that tracks the interaction between two objects within the library (a playlist and a track) rather than a date value field assigned to a single object.

We recommend you submit a feature request for this functionality.

Thank you!

Hi Connor,
Thanks for the feedback.

Let me clarify.
If I click on the header of the “DATE ​​ADDED” column—as you suggested—arrows appear, allowing me to sort in ascending or descending order.
The issue is that, in the “Playlist” view, the “DATE ​​ADDED” column contains no dates—not even the dates when the tracks were originally added to the library. Consequently, even when I click the arrows in the header, the resulting sort order does not correspond to the actual dates the tracks were added, simply because those dates are missing from the “DATE ​​ADDED” column within the playlist view.
Essentially, sorting by “DATE ​​ADDED” only works correctly in the “Tracks” view.
If you look at the two screenshots I sent, you’ll see that in the one labeled “Playlist,” the “DATE ​​ADDED” column is empty, whereas in the “Tracks” view, that column contains dates.
I hope that makes sense.
I’m not sure whether you consider this a system bug or a missing feature—please let me know.
In my view, if it’s not possible to sort tracks by “date added” within a playlist, the functionality is quite limited.
Regarding the other point I raised—the ability to move columns left or right in the view to suit one’s needs—should I submit that as a “feature request”? Thanks! Best regards.

Hi @salandin,

Thank you for the screenshots, they make it clear. The Date Added column shows the date a track was added to your Roon library. In your playlist the column is empty because those tracks are most likely TIDAL tracks that were added to the playlist without being added to your library. Tracks that are not in your library have no library date, so there is nothing to sort by. In the Tracks view you only see library tracks, which is why the dates appear there.

To check, please open one of the tracks from the playlist and see whether it offers Add to Library. If you add the tracks to your library, the column will fill in for them, but the date will be the day you add them, not the day they were added to the playlist.

Roon does not currently store the date a track was added to a playlist, and the columns cannot be rearranged. Both are good suggestions, so please post them in the Feature Suggestions category, where other users can vote for them:

Hi! What’s not quite right with Roon?

· None of the above quite fits

None of the above quite fits

· None of these quite match

Tell us what's going on

· Good morning,
I'd like to resume the thread I posted on October 23rd and respond to Vadim, who last wrote to me.

I read what you wrote, Vadim, but I'm not following you.

I understand that the ADD DATE is always the date the song was added to My Library, and that's fine.

I've always saved all the songs I've saved in the TRACKS section (My Library) to My Library first (from Tidal or directly within Roon) and then saved them to the various playlists.

As you suggested, I tried opening some of the tracks in a playlist, but the ADD TO MY LIBRARY button is grayed out (unclickable) (see attached screenshot). I think that's because I've always added songs to My Library first and then to the playlists.

I also tried searching for new songs not yet in My Library, adding them to My Library directly from Roon, and then saving them to the playlist within Roon, but the DATE ADDED doesn't appear in the DATE ADDED column of the playlist.

So the playlist can't even be sorted by the date added to My Library.

Shouldn't the dates added to My Library at least appear in the DATE ADDED column within a playlist?

Thank you.

Best regards.

Tell us about your home network

· .

Hi @salandin,

If you click on the album you just added from within the playlist, do you still see the “+” option to add the album to your library?

There’s a distinction in Roon between the streaming service version of an object and the library version of the object.

When you add a Tidal track to your library, you spawn a library object (it’s still coming from Tidal, but it’s an object in your database now, not an object in Tidal’s catalog alone). The Date Added field is attached to the library object. This “WOW” playlist appears to be a Tidal playlist porting over to Roon from your Tidal account. The objects inside are going to be streaming objects.

What happens if you create the Playlist in Roon, and then add tracks from your library? Do you see a populated Date Added (to library) field by which you can sort?

Hi @salandin,

We’ve reviewed this with the team in more detail.

This isn’t the ideal UI behavior, but it’s an expected consequence of Roon’s current architecture.

Any playlist stored on a streaming service will always reference the streaming versions of an album, not your library content. If you want your library tracks in that playlist, bring the playlist into your Roon library by selecting “…” → Copy and then use the Playlist Improver to replace the streaming tracks with their library matches.

Hi Connor,
Thanks for your help.

Let’s take it step by step.
First, I’ll tell you that, as you suggested, I created a new playlist directly within Roon and added songs to it directly from My Library within Roon, bypassing Tidal. Indeed, in that new playlist, I see the dates in the DATE ADDED column and can sort the songs by date added.

So, I understand that to see the added dates within a playlist, I have to work exclusively within Roon. If I add songs to that playlist while working in Tidal, the added dates don’t appear in the playlist within Roon.

I’m not sure, however, that I understand your second suggestion, which is to automatically add the ADDED DATES to the chosen playlist by importing them from My Library into Roon.
For example, I went to the WOW playlist in Roon, selected COPY in the menu, and it gave me the option to copy into two playlists (SMART and WOW 2, which I had already created). If I click OK, all the songs from WOW are copied into WOW 2, for example. Then I go to WOW 2 and see the IMPROVE function in the top left, which allows me to match just a few songs with those in My Library. If I then click OK, the songs that IMPROVE matched now actually have the correct ADDED DATES, but they are very few. The remaining songs still don’t have the ADDED DATES visible. Is there a way to import the ADDED DATES into the playlist automatically, or do I have to add the songs not matched by Improve manually, working within Roon?

Could Smart Playlists help me import the correct ADDED DATES into the WOW playlist?

So, ultimately, to get the added dates for a playlist, I can add songs to My Library from both Tidal and Roon, but I only have to add the songs to the playlist from Roon, not Tidal. Is that correct?

I hope I’ve explained myself clearly.

Thank you.

Best regards.

Hi @salandin,

Thanks for testing the Roon-created playlist. That result confirms what’s going on. Taking your questions in order:

1. Getting dates for the tracks Improver didn’t match. The Date Added column only fills in when a playlist entry points to the library version of a track. Nothing can copy library dates onto streaming entries. The automatic route is the Match To Library option in Playlist Improver, which swaps each entry for the Primary Version in your library. For tracks it doesn’t match, you’ll need to swap them by hand: find the track in your library (for example in the Tracks browser), add it to WOW 2, then remove the Tidal version.

2. Smart Playlists. Smart Playlists and saved Focuses are built from your library, so they show Date Added and sort by it. They won’t carry dates into an existing playlist, though. They’re an alternative way to build library-based lists, not a fix for WOW 2. Our guide to saving a Focus covers the setup.

3. Adding tracks from within Roon. Mostly correct. What matters is which version you add, not which app you use. Adding a track from your library in Roon adds the library version, which shows its date. Adding it from Tidal, whether in the Tidal app or from a Tidal result inside Roon, adds the streaming version, which has no library date. Also, keep WOW 2 as a Roon playlist and don’t move it into your Tidal folder. As our playlists article explains, moving a local playlist into a streaming folder replaces its local tracks with streaming ones.

If you’d still like to be able to rearrange columns, please post it in the Feature Suggestions category so the team can track it.