Must sort out my Genre tags

My Genres are a mess, I never really pay much attention to genres and definitely didn’t when I was ripping stuff twenty years ago.
As examples one tag is

What genre do you think would isolate these two albums ?

I think roon has them both with ethnic fusion
I did not listened to the first (I’m doing now, very nice, thanks), the second I did… maybe international blues or blues crossover
I have approx the same problem with tuareg electric guitars, and roon also uses ethnic fusion

Somehow they are both under New Age, amongst others.
:woman_shrugging:. As I said I need to sort stuff… :relaxed:

1 Like

I’ve found there are only two workable genres, “music I like” and “what’s left”. That’s extreme but fine granularity is accompanied by arbitrary classification and music with multiple genres.

If I was after guidance I might start with the professionals. Yale’s summary of LOC common genres:

You can get machine readable formats of the master list:

These have the advantage of been administered by cataloguing authorities, so won’t contain whimsical genres, and will remain fairly static. They may be short on modern sub-genres

2 Likes

I think in my early days of ripping to flac, pre 2000, the less mainstream albums weren’t perhaps as well populated with metadata as now. So if it didn’t know a genre, and I didn’t care about them, I just used to enter pop/rock :relaxed:

1 Like

In many ways that high-level classification is easiest and quite useful. Classical, pop/rock, Jazz… Classical is easiest to sub-divide due to academic interest. I find contemporary music classifications confusing at best for the most part.

2 Likes

I go great detail for classical , with Genre and Sub Genre

So a piano sonata is 05 - Keyboard> Piano Sonata

I split 01 - 10 , orchestral, concerto, chamber, opera etc

The sub split is more arbitrary aimed a navigation with JRiver views

Rock & Pop I leave alone

Jazz is Jazz, Folk is Folk

In Roon I just Roon do it ….

2 Likes

I might break up pop/rock a bit more but Classical at a top level is fine by me :relaxed: I only know the works not what they are in genre sub types.

Is this from a view within Roon? If so, where? Thanks

1 Like

Albums filtered by genre
Album is Faithless 20.

1 Like

Oh I thought you had found a way to show the genre hierarchy as a path :slight_smile:

1 Like