@David_Fenton - if you are still using the Nucleus that you acquired back in 2020, then I’m afraid you can’t use Tailscale, which is only supported on the Nucleus One and Titan models…
It’s possible, although circuitous, to configure a separate computer on your network as a Tailscale subnet router. We don’t commonly recommend this route because it’s the opposite of plug-and-play and requires some proficiency with network settings, terminology, and the command line interface.
If you do choose to give it a shot, you’ll need to follow these specific instructions directly from Tailscale to install the subnet router and set up an access rule for the Nucleus.
It might be easier to just ask your ISP if they can provide a workaround.
Who is your internet service provider?
If your ISP has implemented carrier-grade network address translation (CG-NAT) that blocks port forwarding, you’ll need to inquire if they can assign you a dedicated IPv4 address.
I understand your frustration, and you are absolutely right—those Tailscale instructions are overly complicated.
Let’s forget about them. The most important detail in your post is this: “arc used to work fine.”
The most probable cause is that your Nucleus’s local IP address has changed, and your Netgear Orbi router doesn’t know about it. It’s still sending the ARC request to the old, incorrect address.
Let’s fix this. It’s much simpler than it sounds.
Step-by-Step Guide to Get Roon ARC Working Again
Here is a simple, step-by-step guide. We are just going to check two key places and make sure they match.
Step 1: Find Your Nucleus’s IP Address
We need to know where the router should be sending the traffic.
On your computer or tablet, open the Roon app.
Go to Settings > Setup.
Under your Roon Core (where it says Nucleus), you will see its IP address. It will look something like 192.168.1.X or 10.0.0.X.
Write down or copy these numbers.
Step 2: Check the Port Roon is Trying to Use
In the Roon app, go to Settings > Roon ARC.
You will see the error message, but below (or near) it, you will see the port number. The default is 55000.
Write down this port number.
Step 3: Set Up Port Forwarding on Your Orbi
This is the part that seems intimidating, but we’ll walk through it. We are going to “tell” your router: “Hey, any request that comes in on port 55000, send it directly to my Nucleus at 192.168.1.X.”
On a computer connected to your Orbi network, open a web browser (Chrome, Safari, etc.).
In the address bar, type orbilogin.com or 192.168.1.1 and press Enter.
Log in using your username (usually admin) and your password (if you haven’t changed it, it might be password or printed on a sticker on the router).
Once logged in, find the Advanced tab.
In the Advanced menu, look for the Advanced Setup section.
Click on Port Forwarding / Port Triggering.
Select Port Forwarding (not Triggering).
You will see a list of rules. We need to add a new one. Click Add Custom Service.
Now, fill in the fields:
Service Name: Type something you’ll recognize, like RoonARC.
Protocol: Select TCP.
External Port: Type the port number from Step 2 (probably 55000).
Internal Port: Type the same number (probably 55000).
Internal IP Address:Type the Nucleus IP address from Step 1 here.