I’ve tried everything. What I’m doing now works, for me, better than anything else I’ve done in the past. So first, here’s what I learned and then what I’ve got.
After trying speakers on bookshelves and stands, it’s clear to me that I want my music speakers on my desk. Nothing else has worked well. I want the soundstage you get from facing your left/right channels. I don’t want it behind me or off to the side.
I want the ability to plug in headphones (preferably balanced outs) and I want the jack facing me. I don’t want it on the back of whatever I’m using to drive the headphones.
I want a physical volume control for music and I want to easily adjust the volume independent of the computer’s volume.
I want the computer to be able to do audio out, but I don’t need the audio from the computer to be fantastic.
After trying many different strategies, I’ve learned that I prefer to separate the computer audio out from music (mostly Roon in my case). I don’t want two sets of speaker looking things and I tend to buy monitors that have no built-in speakers.
So, with that, I have this:
- FiiO K17 (not connected to the computer at all)
- Genelec 8030C active speakers (connected with balanced cables to the K17, which drives them in Pre mode)
- a Creative Sound Blaster G55 plugged into the computer over USB-C. My Mac Mini sees it as an audio device and controls the volume. It also has a physical volume knob
I’ve got a pair of excellent condition (green) LSX II boxed up and available for the right sale, if you’re interested. The Genelec are, in my opinion, far superior though they require something to drive them.
The FiiO K17 is great at what it does. I’m very happy with it though I wish it did UPnP but I’m fine with using it for Roon only.
The Creative Sound Blaster is a pretty decent device for what it is. It’s not large and the audio quality is good for PC/Mac stuff. I was never truly happy trying to figure out how to have my desktop music come from a Mac or PC - the options of having Roon run in exclusive mode or use the system mixer just didn’t work for me. This approach does.
Looks like this. Hope this gives you some ideas.