First, I want to applaud how this has been improved over the years, I have raised these issues before. Great work! However, the labor is never done.
-
I have noticed very frequently on Tidal that the album artist and only credit is “Alice Smith & Bob Jones & Charlie Wang” as one string. (It May be extra frequent for me because I am doing a lot of ACT Music and their stuff is particularly poorly annotated.) This is troubling because if I don’t notice it immediately when adding to the library, I have an album artist that is visibly wrong only because the ampersands are blue; when I edit the metadata and add Alice and Bob and Charlie individually, I get white ampersands. But it obviously causes serious malfunctions: this album doesn’t show up under those artists, and when looking at the album there is nothing under By This Artist. And the database is generally messed up. The system now recognizes ampersands and lots of other dividers when I enter the artists explicitly. But it would be very helpful if the system could automatically parse the string and take it apart, when it recognizes known artists and such dividers. I understand automatic processing is risky, but this seems fairly safe.
-
Several times when I have edited the album, removing that compound string and adding the artists explicitly, I still see the compound string in the “now playing” area. This is because lots of albums have redundant track-level credits. Once I started looking for this, I see redundant track credits everywhere. It would be good if those could be removed when the album is added, so that later metadata editing like what I mentioned above and fixed spelling are not undermined by the bad entry remaining at the track level. And it isn’t just redundancy: yesterday I saw “All tracks were composed by Dave Holland”, which is because Dave Holland had album level bass credits but the composer credits were track level, on every track! Ok, this is a rare case. But given the poor quality of metadata in general, not just missing stuff but silly stuff like this, it would be helpful if we could have some clean-up rules.
These complaints are almost exclusively from Tidal, dBPoweramp does a better job. I don’t know why some Tidal albums are so bad, given that Roon identifies the albums against metadata sources…