It appears you have two networks, one with IP addresses of 192.168.0.nnn and the other with addresses of 192.168.86.nnn. Do you have two networks or two routers in your network?
Hi! I have two networks running. The google mesh router runs off the main router which is also the TP Link Network. The Roon Nucleus One is one the google network.
Interestingly, I had the same set up with my previous Roon Core running on a MacMini. and there were no issues with Roon ARC.
Roon requires that all Roon devices must be on the same network (or “subnet”). Is it possible to place your Roon Server and all Roon endpoints either on the same Google network or the same TP-Link network?
The point being that ARC is attempting to connect with the roon server and has to pass through two routers to get to it. You will have to manually set up port forwarding on both routers for it to be able to do this - the automatic setup done by Roon will only be able to use the one router with the Roon Server in its network.
The other option is to use the Google mesh in bridging mode and just have one network in your home.
Thanks for the details. The issue with Roon ARC here is that it needs a direct path to your Roon Server, but in your setup it has to pass through two networks/routers. This is why the automatic UPnP/NAT-PMP configuration cannot complete.
To resolve this, you have a few options:
Single Network Approach:
Configure your Google mesh to operate in bridge mode so that all devices, including the Roon Nucleus One, are on one subnet.
Perform port forwarding or enable UPnP.
This is usually the simplest solution and allows ARC to connect automatically.
Port Forwarding Approach:
Keep both routers, but you will need to manually forward the necessary ports from the Nucleus through both routers to the internet.
ARC requires this if it has to traverse two network segments.
Essentially, for ARC to work properly, it either needs one unified network with port forwarding or UPnP or manual/double port forwarding through both routers.
Would you like instructions for the port-forwarding setup for your specific routers?