What the heck is this all about?
Obviously such a system would require an off-planet backup solutionâŠ
1 Like
Vilvit looks really cool. Iâve been troubled for some time about the dispersion of music files across multiple servers. Itâs barbarically inefficient in a system that has the capacity to transmit links to things as well as the web does. Music is your classic âwrite once, read manyâ use, but itâs small enough that people make multiple copies of it all over the place. Having built a palace, we are living in a hovel against its wall.
Vilvit could solve a lot of problems, including taking uploading out of a Roon Mobile solution, and possibly being able to host the Core in the cloud. Very exciting.
Nothing I have said here should be regarded as âinformedâ by any communication with Roon. Until reading the vilvit webpage I had no idea this was happening. Itâs all speculation on my part.
Also, MQA supports it, but I donât expect it to be MQA files only. That would be a mistake.
3 Likes
The last sentence on the website could be misinterpreted: âIf you want to participate in the effort of making the music industry a greener, bluer, whiter and more responsible place â please get in touch.â
Why whiter?
1 Like
I suspect itâs an ill-judged attempt to refer to snow (whiter = cooler)?
I guess so. More trees, more ocean, more snow.
My response to this would be LOCKSS, Lots of Copies Keeps Stuff Safe. Better if those copies are in the hands of multiple custodians.
Edit Noord are also involved: Secretly Distribution teams with Nordic tech group NoordRights to launch music company Secretly Noord - Music Business Worldwide but they havenât even got their head around HTTPS for their own site. Not exactly brimming with confidence.
Only if you can remember where you stashed itâŠ
1 Like
There is that, although even that can be mitigated by networks of trust, which feels a better solution to this than putting your eggs in one commercial basket.
1 Like
Or all your master tapes in one warehouse?
But it will be interesting to see if it flies.
1 Like
I can jump in here and clarify a little. This is partially my initiative.
Vilvit is an attempt to get all the major actors in the music industry to deliver to and stream from, or deliver to CDNs to be precise, the same repository of music. So - yes, a seed vault for music if you wish. But a lot more operative.
It is ridiculous that every streaming service has to store the same 1-2 petabytes of music in parallel silos over and over again. That you cannot correct metadata for the same files in one place. The modern music industry is founded on old plumbing and Vilvit is attempt at getting enough parties to work together towards both a better infrastructure and a greener industry.
Even co-hosting the long tail that is rarely played would make a great impact.Every service has about 60-80 million tracks of which only 1-10 million are in active duty.
The list of logos should be updated as it now contains both the National Libraries in Scandinavia, the EU and a growing list of interested streaming services. Yes, it might be foilware for now, but it is an honest attempt at helping out both developing a more modern music industry and do our part with energy efficiency.
Roon has of course a lot of expertise in many areas such as metadata and signal path. I also see the comment about LOCKSS. The idea is that there will be redundancy with hosting in many territories but based on green energy relevant to each of them. Norway can offer naturally cooled mountains and cheap hydro power. Other places, solar power would be more relevant.
Yes, it is in its naive phase now, but for a reason. Convincing politicians to fund takes a certain amount of simplification.
9 Likes
Yeah, although the Universal vault fire was apparently started by roofing work the fact that it backed onto the King Kong Ride, animatronics, fire effects and all, tells you they were half asleep at the wheel regardless. Presumably looking after all the music in the world is meant to concentrate minds, but I wouldnât count on it.
Donât be put off - some observations are (intended to be) light hearted!
Itâs a good idea. I hope itâs practicable.
Although off-planet backup would be coolâŠ
1 Like
This all sounds more promising and less like an attempt to corner the music market, thanks for taking the time to clarify. Will be watching with one slightly sceptical eye, but done properly/responsibly it could offer advantages.
1 Like
Skepticism is what will make it work in the end. Thereâs a lot of caveats, but behind the curtain, there are some really promising discussions. And it will be prototyped and shot down many times. But many of the parties behind have decades of experience in the field.
I see that some also speculate about MQAâs role in this. They are one of those who showed early interest, which is greatly appreciated. Itâs should not be read as anything else than they also want to help out.
Weâll try to gather all the files and get Elon to shoot them up in space.
1 Like
Heâd probably be up for itâŠ
2 Likes
Ridicule for whom? Amazon, Google and so on are above happy to have the same data stored multiple times (and payed for as such).
Having multiple data centers with the exact same data (CDN) is not the same with having the same data multiple times in the same place (especially if that place is also part of a CDN).
I could have been clearer, what I meant to infer was: If youâre looking to keep content safe for the long term itâs best not to leave it to a single location/territory, organisation or storage technology. No matter how good or how shiny everything turns to crap in the long-term.
2 Likes