Only in the Nucleus/+ systems
I’m very new to Roon, and got a NUC running ROCK right after my 14 day trial had ended.
Audio-wise I’m loving it!
The main thing I’d like to see is password security on the ROCK web UI and network shares. As someone else mentioned, when you have IT-savvy kids in the house, catastrophic deletion of data or ROCK settings is a very real danger!
Everything is backed up to my NAS, but still a pain to restore everything if it were to happen.
Definitely more machine/os stats on web GUI
Definitely something displayed on the HDMI output
If you can do this already, I haven’t found it but, remove all unused endpoints or the ability to “hide” them, every time I go into the audio setup I have to scroll through all of the HDMI ports on the CORE
and my Google devices I won’t use as endpoints because I have other options in that zone, like a RPi (is this a Roon OS thing or Roon control thing?)
Again, not sure this is happening already but, I have a spinning HDD in my NUC for music storage, is the Roon OS utilizing all of the power saving/mechanical wear and tear reduction that modern drives now have (sorry I don’t know what this stuff is called but I think you may know what I mean), like spinning down or going to standby when not in use? I always thought this had to be “enabled” somehow or, do modern drives do this already, not sure…
Keep up the great work, loving my Roon system so far (new user for about a month now)!
For the ROCK related items, enter the BIOS settings on the NUC and disable HDMI Audio, that will remove those available endpoints found by Roon.
On the other devices, they are available to Roon as they are on your network.
I presume they are they disabled. But the ability to hide available but disable end-points, is a Roon Settings → Audio Settings capability and not for ROCK.
Also, if you want a device that has better HDD management, tracks the SMART attributes of the attached HDD, use a NAS unit.
Certainly my ReadyNAS units come with hardware monitoring on the HDDs, spindown settings, managed shutdown controlled by UPS etc.I then mount my library as a network share on the NAS, and let all the scanning, playback be just another network function.
Upload of codec in ROCK WEB interface would be nice.
Also temperature of CPU, CPU load + RAM usage.
This would reduce quite a number of support tickets here.
Excellent idea, a one click codec auto install mechanism
That might not be allowed for legal reasons. There is a reason they don’t distribute the ffmpeg library. However a user uploading it himself…
That is the point, this leads to massive amount of support - having a simple way of uploading it to the ROCK would lead to a simplified approach for the user to add them to the ROCK. This can not be any more problematic than adding the codec manually the way they currently have to. It is the same thing, just a different approach.
I see you have “more machine/os stats on web ui” in your “on the table” list, and I see a number of replies favoring that. Maybe I can riff on that a bit. I think its one of the most important things roon could do.
I assume we are talking primarily about Roon OS on NUC, or possibly other linux based cores, which hugely simplifies things, making this capability more of a packaging of existing ultilities. For the roon application and heterogeneous machines, some sort of more application oriented snapshot would still be a very useful thing to have, esp for tech support, but its outside the scope of this reply.
web UI or app: you say web UI, and that keeps the clutter away from the roon app.
- An initial implementation could be a simple canned snapshot of the system. give the user (and your technical support) a consistent snapshot. Possible contents would be system description (processor type, SSD size and brand, memory size, system description, etd), then processor load, memory usage, network stats, network stack errors, disk usage and load, processor temperature, fan speed, error messages from system logs. etc. utilities for all this are integral to *nix, so there is no complex development. I don’t know about licensing, but I suspect if the scope is limited to NUC, there are intel diagnostics that might be useful. The tools to do this already exist: uptime, dmesg etc. Can’t think of a bigger band for the buck…
- the snapshot could be downloadable so users could attach it in requests to technical support. A lot of organizations require something like this with good reason
- in addition to informing discussions with support, knowledgeable users could learn what is “normal” for their operation. way back when I did unix sysadmin, one of my first checks on a troubled machine was a few iterations of “uptime” to see how the load was doing. great for realizing you have a runaway process. then “top” to find the bad boy and eliminate it. If I had system stats from the web UI, I’d know what my system should look like under various normal conditions and more easily spot and isolate issues.
- more advanced versions could allow drill-down.
Hope some form of this comes to pass…
If it incurs a cost in terms of RAM or CPU usage that is not of direct benefit to the Roon Server application itself then I would not be in favour of it.
I have thought at various times that having some stats on the web UI about resource usage might be nice, but have come to the conclusion that I don’t really care. I cant change anything relating to the OS anyway so what does it matter? Save as much as you possibly can for the application. If you really want to get the low down on whats happening in the OS, use Windows, macOS or Linux for your core.
All just IMO of course
the caution is understandable. If it helps, I’m talking a packaging of lightweight utilities that have been used for decades for monitoring and diagnostics, and can be run on demand. Should incur very little cost. Maybe you can’t change the OS, but you can provide information to someone so any problems can be diagnosed and fixed faster.
Agreed! Some sort “now playing” visual over HDMI turns the Nuc/Nucleus into a whole new product.
It is only a dream or really a new version of rock is on the way? When?
The very first post in this thread mentions a plan for “later this year”, but I wouldn’t take that as a hard and fast commitment to a delivery date, if I were you.
why they don’t give us some updates every months… I installed rock some days ago… and I find that it is too essential … too much,
I‘d also like to see tools to reduce power consumption, such as:
- timed startup/shutdown
- autostart on power restoration
With the nucleus hidden in a server box in the basement, such tools will help to reduce electrical energy consumption (but will reduce my health, as I won’t exercise on the basement staircase any more…)
This can be enabled in a NUC(leus)’s bios, it’s a bios function. I’ve done it, it works.
- Press F2 on keyboard during start up to go inside BIOS
- Click Advance > Power > Secondary Power Settings > After Power Failure
- Select Power On under After Power Failure
- Press F10 on keyboard to save the changes and exit BIOS
5 posts were merged into an existing topic: By-track or by-album DSP settings