What album have people found that has the most picks ? Leaving aside user defined picks of course. I think Highway 61 Revisited has to be up there with 7/9 tracks as picks.
pity I can’t never agree with editorial picks and first step I take after adding a new album is… marking all tracks as “Pick -> No” 
now… if we could have instead Pitchfork’s comments and ratings… 
I think that you probably need to restrict this to single disc albums, or else box-sets will reign…
Edit: And possibly compilations/various artists vs. original albums 
Miles Davis Kind of Blue, 5/5 100% picks. ((mic-drop))
4 Likes