I notice a lot of "fake” musicians shows in listing of songs and albums in recommended and similar music. I am listening blues mostly and I receive some strange non existing singer and groups in these category like Enlly Blue, Whiskey Blues, Nina Blaze, Jerry,s Sound Room, Sienna Rose …and much mo…

[image] jb76: If by “flag” you mean bringing it to the community’s attention via a forum post… To Roon attention somehow, and the method would largely depend on how widespread a problem this becomes. For instance, phony Pink Floyd albums were removed after flagging in Support > Metadata .

This is a very interesting topic. At what level would we draw the line then? 100% generated or even if just a few stems are AI?

[image] mjw: …the method would largely depend on how widespread a problem this becomes. I spent an hour exploring the AI-generated music site Suno and found quite a few of their artists’ releases on TIDAL and Qobuz. The most recently updated AI artists compiled on Zoundhub are also available…

[image] mjw: The lyrics are awful, and it is clear that a human didn’t pen them My goodness - after all these years to discovers MacArthur Park was AI.

Fake music detection and labeling would be an absolutely tremendous feature. I mean this would be a truly remarkable addition - on by default!

How dare you! :wink: I love Jimmy Webb. Have you listened to Ed Sheeran’s “songs”? Now they are AI for sure. :slightly_smiling_face:

Whilst a couple of posts were made in jest, please do not dilute the discussion by adding further humourous content–it will be moderated. Our preference for a particular style or genre is not the discussion point. What is, is the passing off of AI-generated content as human creativity. If you thin…

Where do we draw the line? What do we mean by AI generated? My understanding is that purely AI-generated music cannot be copyrighted, so there is a whole class of “production” or “industrial” music that requires human “editors” to modify or rearrange AI outputs to ensure the music can be legally own…

I dug a bit deeper and started to realise that this is a can of worms. Traditionally, getting under the hood of something like this means access to a music copyright and/or IP lawyer. Of course, these days, just like a new generation of human musicians, the first port of call is also AI, so musician…

The biggest problem I can see is the people putting out AI tracks that falsely purport to be by established artists. My impression is that Roon (or musicbrainz) keep discography data for distinct artists that would omit these fabrications, as they are not part of any legitimate discography, and ther…

Roon Labs Community

AI music recognition in Roon

Roon Software Discussion

show post in topic

Home
Categories
Guidelines
Terms of Service

Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled