Thank you for reopening this blog and for the recommendations.
After an enjoyable listen to Bach’s Trio Sonatas, I’ve been alternating a Mendelssohn listening adventure with reading and heavy outside woodland work, where the music is natural. Decided to focus on violin concerto in E minor, Op. 64, which has been performed by many soloist/orchestra combinations. One of the more recorded violin concertos in the repertoire. It is easy on the ears, yet has significant complexity and sophistication. Decided to go back a ways to Fritz Kreisler (1926), Joseph Szigeti (1933), Leopold Auer trained performers Jascha Heifetz and Nathan Milstein, David Oïstrakh (with Eugene Ormandy), Yehudi Menuhin, Kyung Wha Chung, Itzhak Perlman, Viktoria Mullova, Anne-Sophie Mutter, Maxim Vengerov, Nigel Kennedy, Gill Shaham, Joshua Bell, Ray Chen, James Ehnes, Allina Ibragimova, Renaud Capuçon, Hilary Hahn, Midori, Christian Tetzlaff and Isabelle Faust. The recordings vary widely in relative microphone precedence given to orchestra and soloist, in soloist performance (particularly the HIP, where the sound gets very thin), in orchestral execution and in the interplay between the two.
The most remarkable part of this adventure was how much I enjoyed the earliest, most primitive (sound engineering) recorded performances. I also found performances where the violin soloist performed spectacularly and the orchestral execution was mediocre (David Oïstrakh gives perhaps my favorite violin performance of the lot, but the overall performance is brought down by the orchestral performance). Also found that I preferred different performers for different movements.
Standout overall performances in this stellar group of performers, where the orchestra and violin soloist most fully complement one another, were
For an enjoyable, soloist-composed cadenza have a listen to Joshua Bell’s recording with Sir Roger Norrington/Camerata Salzburg.
And here is a treat for folks that like to listen, see superb bowing technique and the sheet music at the same time. Can see the third movement in all its glory. Hilary Hahn’s performance here with Paavo Järvi/Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra is superior to her recorded version
I reset my cochlea by interspersing these ½ h Mendelssohn listens with jazz and favorite Natalie Merchant songs. Not that I needed it with the many splendid violin concerto recordings encountered during this exploration.
Would love to hear from others whether this composition and, if so, which performance(s) tickles their fancy.
De gustibus non est disputantum.