MQA first unfold in Roon? MQA? [Delivered in 1.5]

hunts desperately for bottle of mind-bleach

5 Likes

It’s too late. The damage has been done and is permanent. I’ll never be the same again, listening to MQA.

2 Likes

Is that a comment on the lossy MQA mastering process…?

1 Like

I really wish I could say yes, to deflect from the visuals of @miguelito in his very tight trunks :mask::face_vomiting:

:grin:

2 Likes

Jeez! You haven’t even seen my trunks!

2 Likes

I don’t like the way this is un-folding…

:grin:

7 Likes

More blurring please.

2 Likes

RuPaul season 1 vaseline filters on their way

2 Likes

it should be obvious that roon is not going to be able to ever unfold mqa anytime soon if at all. i am betting the latter.

What are you prepared to wager that Roon never unfolds MQA ? Eating of hat or baring of bum in public ?

Edit: I myself will wager unprotected viewing of a pic of Miguelito in his shorts (with reaction video) if it hasn’t happened by 30 June.

4 Likes

at a certain point soon becomes never.

I can’t wait Roon put up its nice ‘shorts’ by then. Patiently waiting…

I love @miguelito ('s) posts on MQA, BUT I do not need an underwear modeling event popping up in the Roon browser…:grinning:

1 Like

Roon are not stupid. If MQA were not coming I think they would simply say so, deal with the fall out and carry on!

how many months have they been saying it’s right around the corner?

If I were Roon: introduction at the high end in Munchen?

It’s a fair question, so I went searching:

The earliest reference I could find was January 16, 2017 just after Tidal introduced MQA Masters. In this interview where Rob Darling was quoted as saying:

“Once we have code from MQA, it should be a matter of single digit days to get it integrated.”

I think it would be fair to call that an “overly enthusiastic” estimate.

In February 2017 Brian walked it back a bit here:

“You’ve been around here long enough to know we don’t put time estimates on anything, but especially not things that involve other companies.
In terms of new features coming, MQA software decoding is our top priority. It’s a top priority for MQA too. We want the same things you do, and we are well aware of the massive demand for this feature.
We’ll share more when there’s more to share.”

In July 2017 Roon introduced MQA detection in Build 242. No news at that time about MQA unfolding.

Then a long silence until MQA announced that Roon was onboard at CES 2018. I understand that this marked the end of negotiations and entry into a commercial agreement. The technical development commenced after this.

In January 2018 Brian confirmed that Roon would do the first unfold when MQA support was released but didn’t give any estimate as to time.

So you can pick either January 2017 or January 2018. Clearly negotiations took a lot longer than expected, but contracts have now been signed and implementation is under active development.

Like Henry, I believe that if for any reason they were not going to unfold MQA then they would simply tell us. What could be gained from sitting on such news ?

4 Likes

I checked a certain computer software player that implemented MQA - between their earliest public announcement (that I can find) and the actual release of the MQA decoding feature, it toke them 6 months. Usually a company should have started work on stuff before public announcement, so the actual time is very likely to be even longer.

Roon is considerably more sophisticated in functionality and architecture than the other software players, so it is an even larger challenge to get it done.

1 Like

Roon has to unfold MQA soon! It is the only way to stop the endless stream of MQA threads…No doubt they will be replaced by another endless stream of ‘MQA sounds good/bad/what’s all the fuss about’ threads.

2 Likes

Isn’t the delay all due to business decisions right now? MQA wants money from all users of Roon and Roon wants to give money for users that uses MQA (or something similar)?

I would guess DSP after first unfold could also be a somewhat sensitive issue for the MQA guys.