The Suspense Is Killing Me

Roon will announce the Best of Artist Foreheads for 2019.

7 Likes

Just fix the latest version first before anything else.

5 Likes

Haven’t seen that Roon is presently focused on security.

1 Like

The devs have said for a while that they would prefer to rollout new features as projects reach maturity through smaller, more frequent updates rather than a compendious huge one. Somehow, however, circumstances seem to conspire so that we end up with a major release at one of the most inconvenient times of the year. I believe Roon wants this to change, rather than continue.

What do you base this on? I haven’t seen posts about there back end systems?

There are occasional posts about the back-end infrastructure from the Roon team, generally in response to an issue; for example:

It only transcodes if necessary. If you have the bandwidth on both sides to stream 50 Mbps 4k Blu-Ray, it’ll make it happen.

It obviously is a concern.

You should quarantine your “entertainment” stuff, anyway. Easier said than done, of course, especially if you’re integrating over C4 or something, but I’d be less concerned about exposing a port or two on a frequently-updated system like ROCK / Nucleus than I’d be installing one of the thousands of Internet of Shit appliances. Then again, how many people around you are running updated perimeter devices, let alone are diligent with simple maintenance like OS updates, or make that a buying point when they purchase things like (non-google-built android, cough, cough) cell phones ? How many users of @allo.com products have you seen pestering them for updates to the antiquated linux that’s running on the USBridge instead of just leaving it at their “meh, not our fault, sry, bye”, answer ?

You can configure Plex to limit bandwidth of external access regardless of the connection. I do this to make it easier to get it anywhere. Any device with Plex can also be configured to pull an even lower bandwidth if necessary. For me this feature would be essential for mobile Roon.

Yeap.

I understood the hypothetical as “would Roon be able to pull HiRes from a user’s Core” (as opposed to the cloud), the answer to which is “if Plex is any indicator, absolutely, yes”.

Obviously, there needs to be a bit of end-user education if there’s on the fly recompression in some cases, for example, that no matter what your ears, headphones or car system, it’s rather improbable that you’d hear the difference between LAME -V0 and 24/192 in public transport or while driving.

2 Likes

I would love CD quality for mobile, that’s plenty for most.

Absolutely, but there’s exactly nothing RoonLabs can do about it if the bandwidth isn’t there.

It also isn’t “difficult” (Plex does it) in many developed areas, it’s just that people need to understand they’re likely not going to be able to stream Step by Step, in CD quality, in the middle of the Sahel. They also need to understand that there’s a reason to “but Spotify worked”.

Then there’s probably about a gazillion other issues, including what you’re allowed to copy over, both from the perspective of, say, Apple, and rights-wise in general, if you do DSP where do you do it, where you store the metadata if you want the experience to be good, having to deal with a gazillion different ISPs and their crappy hardware + peering, and you have to do all for a crowd that’s not necessarily tech-savvy, so, well - wish the RoonLabs guys good luck, and hope it works out :wink: .

There is a very good reason why Spotify, Tidal, Qubuz and Apple have offline playback.

It is simply naive to believe that you can stream directly from your Roon Core while in a car or especially on a plane without using offline playback.

It is actually not very interesting what you can do on a good connection, remember it also has to work in areas with bad coverage.

I agree and this is why for me having a mobile capability in Roon is not a high priority. Just use TIDAL/Qobuz when on the move, since they have already solved these issues and don’t require me to open up my home network at all.

Of course if the Roon mobile solution was to put the entirety of the Core functionality in the cloud that’s a different matter, but I don’t really see how it works with local content.

I’m not sure it will come (Mobile), because Roon won’t be able to guarantee the best experience in all cases - which will be largely dependent on factors out of their control. I don’t want to upload my library somewhere or open my home network either.

2 Likes

I agree why do I need to access MY albums when Tidal has 99+% of them.

For out of house use an iPad, Audioquest Dragonfly Red And a pair of decent headphones, in my case Bose QC 25 and you have a pretty ok system

I suppose it depends how much time this has to be your only system.

Data costs in South Africa are horrendous anyway so streaming hi res from home would be extortionate so 44.1 or heaven forbid MP3

At my age , after years of Led Zeppelin at mach 9 can I really tell the difference

2 Likes

This is the point. My comment about data going through Roon’s servers was ironic. Probably the only way it’ll work for me is offline. Signal is not the same everywhere.

The post linked by Geoff was the main thing I was referring to. It’s a good long description by Brian about their work to speed up the features that rely on connections with the Roon server farm. My point was/is that if mobile adds ANY stress to that network then they probably have work to do before it can be released.

To me Roon mobile would be about accessing (1) Tidal/Qobuz, and (2) downloaded local content to the mobile device, through a Roon-lite interface that pushes play statistics back to the home installation and accesses some of the metadata and organizational efforts within the home installation - whether that is playlists, favorites, etc., remains to be seen. Perhaps it will also support tagging and favoriting and such while using mobile.

It would be a Roon-lite experience and I agree I don’t think it is necessary to stream from the home installation, but Roon could take charge of storing some level of the home collection on the mobile device.

1 Like

I don’t think going mobile is a path to explore for Roon. Everything is available for that already: DAP+DAC+TIDAL/Qobuz.

Where is the value of Roon ? None.

Instead I’d rather see the huge gap aligned between remote & core rather than an “on the go Roon”.

I tend to agree. I’d rather see a better sync between non-mobile locations (home and office) rather than an on-the-go solution. But others would like to see it and there is definitely some validity to it given that other music solutions offer it. And Roon has said they’re working on it, which indicates they may already be heavily invested in it.

For me if you could just echo your library and playlists in Tidal (Qobuz) that would be enough as all the rest of the infrastructure is there then. I’d happily go without the niceties of play counts etc.

3 Likes