I just wanted to get other forum members’ opinions on this.
Without a doubt, the black-stuff is back
DG, Abbey Road and MoFi (to name but a few) are all reinvesting/reinvigorating their vinyl mastering facilities, and pressing-plants apparently can’t keep up with consumer demand.
Has the world gone crazy? Vinyl is noisy, technically-limited (compared to digital), and bloody expensive to boot.
Why, oh why, won’t this revival ‘run out of steam’? I speak as someone who has been, and continues to be heavily invested in vinyl. I treasure my vinyl collection, and have probably added about twenty-titles to it in the last month alone.
But it’s an archaic format that belongs in the last century, with replay equipment that was devised a generation ago.
Vinyl has been a niche-format for the last thirty-years, since the ascendancy of CD in the mid-nineties.
I can understand the ‘novelty’ factor of spinning a piece of plastic navigated by a diamond stylus, but why isn’t this novelty ‘wearing off’?
Hi-res is not an answer to vinyl because hi-res is not an answer to anything. As the OP said, it has nothing to do with quality per se, although, as the article explains, you can abuse digital in ways you can’t vinyl.
I didn’t say that it’s cheaper I have a quite fine digital setup and don’t listen to vinyl much, but recently I put a record onto my P10 and was a bit blown away by how nice that sounded.
Note: I am not speaking about what has objectively higher fidelity
Anyway, that’s just a side issue for people with really good vinyl setups. For the vast majority the vinyl resurgence is IMHO about the first thing I mentioned
Bill_Janssen
(Wigwam wool socks now on asymmetrical isolation feet!)
8
Problematic article there:
…here we have a solid example of why many people buy vinyl records in order to access a less dynamically compressed master.
And two paras earlier:
Roon reports DR5 for both the 24bit/44.1kHz digital download and the 16bit/44.1kHz vinyl rip.
I think it’s a juxtaposition of two factors; baby boomers that grew up with vinyl now have the money and time to go back to something they remember fondly, and millennials have adopted vinyl as an ironic and archaic hobby.
Again, I agree. I was looking at it from a technical aspect only. I personally like the sound of harpsichord. Anyway, the piano-harpsichord comparison is quite dissimilar to the vinyl-digital comparison, so I guess I should have found a better analogy.