I have a list, but I’ll start with one.
Todd Rundgren’s Something/Anything?. This album gets huge kudos from critics. Todd admirably does everything himself (writes, sings, plays all instruments, produces) and yet… I can’t get into it at all.
I suspect I have to give sides 2-4 a listen again, but even if I find some songs I like, I can’t get behind the production (I have the same problem with a few other albums he produced).
What albums do you know you should like, but don’t?