Classical Box Sets that are not identified by Roon

thanks. i have 410 out of 2749 unidentified, nearly 15%!

1 Like

My 6% is generous. There are a number of identifications that are close, but not the actual recording (it identifies as a download rather than a CD). IN addition, quite a few of my box sets are not identified – I treat each box set as 1 CD in my count, but many consist of 40+ CDs.

It also took a lot of work and searching to come up with this number.

2 Likes

I just recalculated on a track basis, and its closer to 15%.

I just thought I’d add my own list of box sets which are unidentified. They often have placeholders in Allmusic, below. Or some metadata, but not enough to make the boxes usable (i.e. no performance dates/venues).

If all these were fixed, I’d have many thousands of tracks finally accessible, which are currently “lost”.

Just to reiterate, classical box sets need not just full credits, but also performance dates and venues. There are often so many multiple performances of each work by the same performer, that this is absolutely necessary.

(This is mostly for @joel :slight_smile:)


Beaux Arts Trio: 60 Years (60CDs)

Boulez: Complete Columbia (67CDs)

Brendel: Complete Phillips recordings (114CDs)


Roon has incomplete metadata but I don’t think it’s from Rovi. This box definitely needs dates and venues, as there are many multiple performances.

Cortot: Anniversary Edition (40CDs)


It’s there but it has NO PERFORMANCE DATES. Which is utterly useless with this kind of a box: it has sometimes more than 5 performances of the same work, and they are therefore impossible to distinguish.

Freire: Complete Columbia Recordings (7CDs)

Gould: Original Jacket Collection (2007) (80CDs)

Haydn Quartets Festetics (19CDs)


I sent the complete track listing to Rovi and they did nothing about it. :unamused:

Horowitz: Carnegie Hall Live (Sony) (41CDs)

Kovacevich: Complete Phillips (25CDs)


There is metadata in Roon, but it is very faulty, with 85 tracks which don’t match and no dates. It also has the wrong work title format, so I guess isn’t from Rovi. Rovi needs to do this properly.

Monteux: Complete RCA Album Collection (40CDs)

Quartetto Italiano: Complete Decca Philips and DG Recordings (37CDs)


Roon comes up with something incomplete but 219 tracks don’t match and it’s basically useless.

Rachmaninov Compete Piano Works Ashkenazy (11CDs)


Has metadata but needs performances dates as there are multiple performances.

Richter: 100th Anniversary Edition (50CDs)

In total about 600 unidentified CDs, just in the box sets listed in this post.

1 Like

In addition to the box sets I listed above, add:

Mercury Living Presence 3: The Collectors Edition (53 CDs)

Seon Collection (85 CDs) (2015) Sony Classical

Das Alte Werk (50CDs) Warner Classics

Piano Masterworks: The Worlds Favorite Piano Classics (50 CDs) http://www.allmusic.com/album/piano-masterworks-worlds-favourite-piano-var-mw0001867138

Vivarte: The 60-CD Collection http://www.allmusic.com/album/vivarte-the-60-cd-collection-mw0002488462

The All-Baroque Box: From Monteverdi to Bach (50CDs) http://www.allmusic.com/album/the-all-baroque-box-from-monteverdi-to-bach-mw0002385235

Another 348 CDs

2 Likes

The 18CD collection issued on EMI Classics in 2011 under the title Delius 150th Anniversary Edition.

Ludwig thought that Rovi had a placeholder for it back in February, but it’s still not known to Roon.

Edit: Allmusic has just a placeholder. Discogs seems to know more about it:

1 Like

Please always include an Allmusic link if there is one. And if not, Discogs and/or the original record company listing. It will save the Roon team (mainly @joel) a huge amount of time in following up these problems.

Another one from me:

Katchen: Complete Decca Recordings (36CDs)
Roon has nothing.
Placeholder: http://www.allmusic.com/album/julius-katchen-the-complete-decca-recordings-mw0002961963
Multiple performances of the same work. Needs performance dates and venues.

1 Like

Francis Poulenc: Oeuvres complètes (20 CDs)
Placeholder: http://www.allmusic.com/album/release/poulenc-oeuvres-complètes-complete-works-mr0003785820
Amazon has the track list: https://www.amazon.com/Poulenc-complètes-1963-2013-LÉdition-anniversaire/dp/B0091JQH76
Performers: http://www.arkivmusic.com/classical/Name/Jacques-Jouineau/Conductor/139969-3

George Szell: The Edition (49 CDs)
Allmusic placeholder: http://www.allmusic.com/album/george-szell-the-edition-mw0002581593
Tracks & venues: http://www.goodwinshighend.com/music/classical/Szell/George%20Szell%2049%20CD%20Box%20Set.htm

Bruno Walter: The Edition (39 CDs)
Allmusic placeholder: http://www.allmusic.com/album/bruno-walter-the-edition-mw0001938566
Tracks: http://www.goodwinshighend.com/music/classical/Bruno%20Walter/Bruno%20Walter%2039%20CD%20Box%20Set.htm
Recording dates (relevant because of multiple recordings): https://www.sonymusicshop.jp/m/item/itemShw.php?cd=01DE000048952

Georg Solti: Soltissimo 1 (40 CDs)
No placeholder at Allmusic
Tracks: http://www.hmv.co.jp/en/artist_Classical-Collection-Boxed-Set_000000000088040/item_Solti-Soltissimo-1-the-Recordings-By-Georg-Solti-On-Decca-In-Early-Years-cd_7156035

Georg Solti: Soltissimo 2 (53 CDs)
No placeholder at Allmusic
Track list: http://www.hottracks.co.kr/ht/record/detail/8808678141030

Georg Solti: Soltissimo 3 (57 CDs)
No placeholder at Allmusic
Tracks & venues: http://www.aria-cd.com/arianew/shopping.php?pg=label/deccadn0035

Georg Solti: Soltissimo 4 (39 CDs)
No placeholder at Allmusic
Contact me, I can provide a list of tracks & venues

I have copied the info from the above websites, so contact me in case they disappear

1 Like

It’s a mystery to me why Decca classics has never issued any big Solti box sets, with Korea the only source. He was one of their biggest selling artists. Puzzling.

1 Like

Pierre Fournier - Aristocrat of the Cello (6 CDs)
Allmusic Placeholder: http://www.allmusic.com/album/pierre-fournier-aristocrat-of-the-cello-united-kingdom-mw0001427018
Complete info: http://www.deutschegrammophon.com/de/cat/4775939

1 Like

Leonard Bernstein Edition: Concertos & Orchestral Works (80 CDs)
Allmusic Placeholder: http://www.allmusic.com/album/leonard-bernstein-edition-concertos-orchestral-works-mw0002744902

1 Like

Neville Marriner - The Argo Years
Allmusic Placeholder: http://www.allmusic.com/album/the-argo-years-mw0002630885
Complete information: http://www.deccaclassics.com/fr/cat/4786883

1 Like

The Art of Leonid Kogan (15 CD)
Allmusic Placeholder: http://www.allmusic.com/album/the-art-of-leonid-kogan-mw0002711686

Its pretty obvious that Roon needs a lot of work with its identification of classical music!!

Well, more accurately they need to work with their metadata providers to improve the metadata provided. This thread helps them to do that.

Mozart: Piano Concertos / Schiff, Vegh
Allmusic Placeholder: http://www.allmusic.com/album/mozart-klavierkonzerte-mw0001856836
Complete info: http://www.deutschegrammophon.com/en/cat/4481402

Bernard Haitink: The Philips Years
Allmusic Placeholder: http://www.allmusic.com/album/haitink-the-philips-years-mw0002560001
Complete info: http://www.deutschegrammophon.com/de/cat/4785671?sort=newest_rec&SearchString=haitink+years&ADD_OTHER=1

1 Like

Noriko Ogawa - Debussy - The solo piano works

1 Like

In my original post, I did not include the links. For those albums that others have not posted links to:

A Festival of Ballet (50 CD Set): EMI Classics http://www.allmusic.com/album/festival-of-ballet-box-set-mw0001875928
11 Kurzopern (Original Electrola One Act Operas 1975-1980) (11 CD SET): Warner Classics http://www.allmusic.com/album/11-kurzopern-the-original-electrola-one-act-operas-mw0002356507
ICON - Annie Fischer: The Complete London Studio Recordings (8 CD Set): Warner Classics http://www.allmusic.com/album/the-complete-london-studio-recordings-mw0002621782
Arthur Rubinstein plays Chopin (10 CD): Sony Classical https://www.discogs.com/Arthur-Rubinstein-Arthur-Rubinstein-plays-Chopin/release/5408135
Arturo Toscanini: The Complete RCA Collection (85 CD): RCA Red Seal http://www.allmusic.com/album/arturo-toscanini-the-complete-rca-collection-mw0002321063
Arturo Toscanini: The HMV Recordings (6 CD): Warner Classics http://www.allmusic.com/album/icon-arturo-toscanini-mw0002472661
Bach Masterworks - The Original Jackets Collection [50 CD][Limited Edition]: Deutsche Grammophon https://www.discogs.com/Bach-Masterworks-The-Original-Jackets-Collection/release/5081132
Bernard Haitink: The Symphony Edition [36 CD][Limited Edition]: Decca Classics http://www.allmusic.com/album/bernard-haitink-the-symphony-edition-mw0002611220
Bruno Walter conducts Mahler (7CD): Sony Classical http://www.allmusic.com/album/bruno-walter-conducts-mahler-mw0002311512
Bruno Walter conducts Mozart (6 CD): Sony Classical http://www.allmusic.com/album/bruno-walter-conducts-mozart-mw0002186751
Carlo Maria Giulini - The London Years (17 CD): Warner Classics http://www.allmusic.com/album/carlo-maria-giulini-the-london-years-mw0002586602
Charles Munch conducts Romantic Masterworks (8 CD): RCA Red Seal http://www.allmusic.com/album/charles-munch-conducts-romantic-masterworks-mw0002115736
David Zinman: Great Symphonies Zurich Years (50CD): RCA Red Seal http://www.arkivmusic.com/classical/album.jsp?album_id=1216670
Phase Four Stereo Concert Series [41 CD][Limited Edition]: Decca Classics http://www.allmusic.com/album/phase-4-stereo-stereo-concert-series-mw0002698063
Icon: Edwin Fischer - Piano Playing from the Heart (12CD): Warner Classics http://www.allmusic.com/album/icon-edwin-fischer-piano-playing-from-the-heart-mw0002025202
Ernest Ansermet: French Music (32 CD): Decca Classics http://www.arkivmusic.com/classical/album.jsp?album_id=1012778
Ernest Ansermet: Russian Music (33 CD): Decca Classics https://www.amazon.com/Ernest-Ansermet-Russian-Nicolai-Rimsky-Korsakov/dp/B00J498SOI
Ernest Ansermet: The Great European Tradition (31CD): Decca Classics http://www.allmusic.com/album/the-great-european-tradition-mw0002758005/releases
Eugene Ormandy conducts 20th Century Classics (12CD): Sony Classical http://www.allmusic.com/album/eugene-ormandy-conducts-20th-century-classics-mw0002407752

2 Likes

All of the above have been submitted to Rovi for consideration. We wait…

Many thanks @joel for your work in encouraging Rovi to fill these gaps!

1 Like