Since M1 with its insane performance and Apple Minis available for less money than a Nucleus, it is only fit to use such hardware as a roon server. A 256GB SSD is more than enough to host the database even for huge libraries. The music may reside on a Network drive (as this data provision is not really critical for performance. See streaming high res also works seamlessly…). The fan on such a mini will never start doing anything and the box will remain cool - no comparison to a intel based platform. You could put a bar of chocolate on it - it would never melt.
What is more - those minis are not looking that bad and could be placed also where you can see them actually. Adding an intona usb isolator for instance you never worry about noise or so again.
I’d really see no good reason anymore to go for a Nucleus which is not better looking, not cheaper, not more powerful - in short not any better but the contrary.
But… roonlabs managed now to get the Macs out of the way with some “feature” making the server on such a platform permanently “initializing”.
Roonlabs cannot really believe Apple will ever be more willingly to cooperate (e.g. to let roon use Apple Music), if not even the hardware is supported natively.
I’m really happy with the roon software and for that I have a lifetime license. But this is really annoying now.
Ronny maybe you should read some other threads before posting as you will see that @danny has already said that they are testing the M1 native version of Roon.
Roon will never really be a truly native app as it runs on top of DotNet and that has not that long (in the scheme of things) been migrated to M1 native Mac’s. Everyone that bought an M1 Mac before that was only going to get emulation, even if that is very good.
Other than that yes it will make an excellent Roon server, but it’s not like Rock in that never needs to be touched as it has Apple updates, which have broken multiple of my MacBooks in the past (I had to recover my late 2015 MacBook Pro after the last major upgrade and my 2020 Air was made useless by an upgrade and had to be wiped, along with several of my colleagues).
Nucleus is for users that want an appliance and do not want to tinker with a computer ever, from the moment they turn it on and plug in the Ethernet cable. Can a tech savvy friend do this for you, yes, so Nucleus is not really for people like us, but it still has a place.
In a year or two I might well swap my my nicely working Intel NUC 10 (cheaper than a Mac mini) running Rock for an M2 Mac so it can also run HQPlayer as well on the same machine. I think it will be amazing when it is fully working and released and debugged.
Because it is way faster, using much less power. It stays cool and looks nicer, while it is cheaper.
What else? Maybe… because it could be used for other stuff also (could!) and it is rather stable in price. So I could sell it again. But yeah a cheap aluminium box with a NUC, i5 and SSD included and with a tailor made software for it pays off because it warms in winter as class A amps do. But now it is summer.
…That and connect you to apples eco system and all that benefits Apple.
The Mac mini runs MacOS, but MacOS is not the problem, the new hardware is the problem. And the hardware problem has created a software problem, as the hardware is currently depending on a piece of software (a band aid, provided by Apple) to allow older software to run on there hardware. Several other developers are experiencing errors because of decisions and or actions made by Apple.
And with this big mess, Roon software that once played well with Apple is not working well with Apple’s hardware/software band aid combo. But Apple is never at fault, they can do no wrong. (Sarcasm) They don’t care about Roon… Apple does everything right with their hardware and software decisions (well everything that benefits Apple).
Apple made its decision. Now everyone, jump! I hate that about Apple.
That’s exactly what I am doing now. I was running Roon and HQPlayer Embedded on a sonicTransporter i9. The M1 Mac mini has proven to be every bit as powerful and easy to maintain running Roon Server and HQPlayer Desktop.
I upsample PCM and DSD to DSD256 and pass that on to my Holo Audio May KTE DAC using the ASDM7ECv2 modulator and poly-sinc-gaus-xla (1x) and poly-sinc-gaus-hires-lp (Nx). That takes serious horsepower!
I do agree that the M1 can run intel apps with Rosetta2 faster than some intel Macs run intel apps, but not all intel apps run flawlessly with Rosetta2. Rosetta2 is a bandaid.
The roon problems are a good example of Rosetta2 translation not working well with an intel app. Maybe it’s not the server app, maybe it’s RAAT, perhaps networking code, Idk… but something obviously doesn’t translate correctly…
So until a native arm app is released, Roon faster on a M1, crash faster too.