Roon UI is not good enough for $150 per year

Well, I was talking about MS 365 as a personal (family) subscription, not as a professional tool.
Or, perhaps, you consider that nobody pays personal licences to Microsoft and they pretend using their professional profile at home ? :wink:

I was alluding to the fact that Office is a business/educational tool, if it’s used otherwise so be it. However, there are perfectly good free examples to be had for families who don’t use it professionally.

Notwithstanding, Roon is niche and Office is not.

Alas, I did not say that, nor did I allude to that to be clear. How one choose to use any Microsoft tools/software or any of the alternatives is completely up to them.

Cheers. :musical_note:

If you are not even subscribing and using Roon, why are you even here? You clearly made a decision to leave as Roon does not meet your standards. That’s ok. Do you post in all the other forms who create software you are not happy with?

A philosophical point. Nothing is perfect, if you look hard enough you can and will find fault in anything. So, the question is; are you looking for faults or exploring solutions?

Exploring solutions can be done so much more constructively by being polite and well mannered. Also consider that so many users are not having the issues you experienced, which may indicate there are other factors outside Roon at play here.

Roon’s pricing policy and their reasons behind it have been published clearly and in detail on this very forum.

Just my thoughts…

7 Likes

Yeah thanks… but I did subscribe in the past and hope springs eternal that things will change… Oh I get monthly forum summaries… So that’s why I’m here today.

What on earth does this mean? is what a complete sentence? I assume English is your first language, but the reply above is nonsensical.

OK I got the reply to you mixed up, it was Outlay in Canada, so sorry, it was midnight here and I lost focus…

However the fact remains that if you had originally posted something like " hey, I personally have issues with the UI and believe it could be improved to make Roon better. I have posted feature requests in the past regarding the UI but they have not resulted in any change. How about… and then your suggestion…

Then you would probably got a good deal of support and encouragement from others.

Instead it seems you posted looking for a fight and childishly continue to be rude. Pity, because your open API for 3rd Party UI changes idea is potentially quite a good one.

Fairwell, I hope the rest of your life is a happy one without Roon.

5 Likes

Typed in “$120 USD = $170 AUD.” and the forum software was not happy, wouldn’t let me post and told me “Body seems unclear, is it a complete sentence?”.

As if… They’re not wasting any time on an API it’s just a pipe dream, and anyway Roon takes no notice, never responds, ever… they can’t even get the subscription model right. There is NO MONTHLY SUBSCRIPTION… It’s a yearly subscription “Billed Yearly” with some bs about it being $9.99/month.

1 Like

For goodness sake!

The OP of this thread was hardly “slightly critical” in his post! - just *$%$"£% rude!

For what my opinion is worth, the Roon UI is pretty damn good. If the OP genuinely wants to provide suggestions to improve his experience with the product, then that is absolutely fine. However, given the tone of his post at the top of this thread there is no evidence of this, and he would probably be better off looking elsewhere for a UI to use with his system.

4 Likes

A bit off topic but in response to a comment here:
I managed to sign up for Qobuz USA without living in a Qobuz country. Once you sign up and pay (and they pay royalties acc’d to the signup country), they don’t care where you are in the world, you can use the service. You can travel and move countries, it’s irrelevant.
I don’t see why Roon would have any reason or interest in dealing with any of that. It’s not their issue or business.

As far as the OP issues: I’m not in the US or Europe and have none of those issues. I don’t have super high speed internet, either. I even get good results if I work behind a VPN that seriously slows down my internet speed.
So I don’t think several of your issues have anything at all to do with Roon itself. Maybe your ISP or home networking issues. Just because you assume you setup and network are working optimally, it doesn’t mean they are.

1 Like

I still fail to see why you don’t complain to Tidal rather than Roon? Or are there differences between how the Tidal application works compared to Tidal through Roons GUI?

1 Like

Tidal (for mobile) allows offline downloads, unfortunately the Windows version doesn’t.

But guess what Spotify for Windows does allow downloads, go figure!

Anyway…for $120 a year Roon should be able to better buffer the playing track, I’m sure that wouldn’t invalidate their Tidal licencing.

I don’t mind waiting say 30 seconds for buffering at the very start of the album if it means absolutely no stutters during the playing of the album. I think the longest stutter I get is about 10 seconds, so a 30 second buffer should fix that. Ofc it could be an “opt-in” for people with issues like me, so those not affected by stutters don’t wait at all.

1 Like

Hi Danny,

Yes, I did say there were workarounds or vpn opportunities to get around the terms of service and restrictions that exist outside Qobuz supported countries.

In so far as Roon is concerned and it being none of their business that’s likely true. However, what I may not have made clear, I’ve not read back up, was that I meant if there was an issue with Qobuz and a Roon user who was not legally/technically allowed to use the service, perhaps Roon would not be able to provide the support they would as they do otherwise. (Perhaps I’m wrong).

Cheers.

If the UI is the only consideration, I’d say Roon is better than the other music application software I’ve tried in the past two years or so (including Audirvana, Tidal, Bluesound, iTunes, and the Matrix Audio player), in terms of overall ease-of-use, data management, hardware integration and control, reliability, and user support (considered all together, not necessarily in every individual feature). For any support request, I usually get a forum response (often from a technical expert if not a Roon staff member) within hours. I don’t think any other application comes close in that regard.

There are always issues with any software this complex. As for price, I agree that $120/year seems rather high, especially when you also add monthly fees for a Tidal/Qobuz subscription. But then, it is not a mass market product but more of a niche product for a small, relatively affluent user-base. My cable TV subscription costs about the same per month as Roon does per year (and almost all I ever watch is news, aside from streaming content like Netflix/Hulu/Amazon with additional subscription costs). With Roon + Tidal/Qobuz, one can access nearly all the world’s music (in high res formats) for about $1 daily. What other major, high quality media service is cheaper? My Sunday newspaper costs $3.50/week.

Do you even use Tidal with Roon?

And yes, I’m using Foobar2000 for my ripped CD’s (flacs) and internet radio, and Tidal desktop player for Tidal… Yes Tidal desktop stutters too sometimes (just like Roon)… So there’s no value in Roon (for me) at $120 USD a year… If Roon can fix the Tidal stutters (like better buffering) then it would be a buy, because the metadata is so good, really that’s the only advantage it has over Foobar IMO.

Sorry, i didn’t make myself clear. What i’m saying is that for most of us there are no buffering or stutters while playing back from Tidal (or Qobuz or local files either for that matter).

So i assume that the Tidal load balancing/service delivery is not working as intended in your area. And Roon does not change Tidals infrastructure as far as i know, and is not responsible for their flaws.

Either that or your network is not up to the task of streaming audio. It wouldn’t be the first time someone, often with extensive IT experience, is claiming “i’ve no issues whatsoever with any other streaming service, but Roon sucks and my network is flawless”. :wink:

Once again it would be very beneficial if Roon had some form of network/hardware performance index tool built in…

1 Like

Come on guys lets be honest, the interface is a weak point ATM.
I’m currently exploring PLEX (i have a full PLEXpass) and mConnectHD on my UPNP/DLNA devices. PLEX and mConnectHD both look and feel nicer to use IMHO.

mConnectHD is a £6 app…
PLEX is like roon, it offers just as much metadata and artist info, but offers much more from its platform. A PLEXpass is £95 (liftime) or £3.99 per month

3 Likes

Just to touch on your thoughts about price comparisons, I do feel it’s rather awkward to compare to other non music services, especially those that may not form a niche market. Your Sunday newspaper for example doesn’t require any further cost. To use Roon, one must have all the equipment either in the first instance or to purchase with Roon such as a Nucleus. And we all know what some of our gear can cost or has induced further spending to meet the needs of Roon.

I’m neither saying this is good or bad, just further exploration is needed when looking at the cost of subscription and making comparisons.

Cheers.

1 Like

My impressions were based on the content of your posts.

6 Likes

I made a couple of Bug fix / “feature” requests re. UI, if you would care to check up.

I also use mConnect HD for my Oppo and atm a borrowed Gold Note DS-10. If you seriously believe that the mConnect GUI is better than Roons, there’s hardly anything to discuss. I have to say that i think there are very few people here that would like Roon to become more like mConnect…

2 Likes

Yep. Clearly. Some of the old Roonies just keep aggressively defending their position. It may not be the worst interface around but could most definitely do a lot better.

1 Like