Should we be putting our foot down with Tidal or Roon's implementation of it?

[Rugby (aka Daniel or Big Dan)]

This topic has actually been discussed several times over the past year. The latest in-depth thread was in October, I think. In that thread, Brian posted a pretty detailed post which I’m going to link here.

Tidal albums get lost

From TIDAL’s perspective–you added release X to your library, and release X is no longer licensed to you, therefore it is gone. In their world, this is working as designed. They do not make the licensing decisions, and our investigations have concluded that everything is working how it was designed to work on their end and on ours–I don’t think anyone here has the power to make the labels stop changing licenses over time. I agree that the resulting behavior isn’t ideal, but there is a big diffe…