An attempt was made in the late 70s by Sony to do just that in the form of the Elcaset:
But it was unsuccessful 
.
3 Likes
Add DAT to that attempt as well…
2 Likes
I had an Akai 4000d then moved up to a Revox A77, (early 1970’s) while the reproduction from the Revox even at the lower speed (3.75 ips) was excellent , tapes are a faff to say the least and the space they take up , well , especially if you go for 7.5 ips. I used mainly the 10.5 in NAB reels.
Eventually I started on cassettes a Yamaha TC800 (the sloping one) followed by 3 x Nakamichi ultimately the CR7e.
TBH the CR7e knocked the socks of the Revox even on noise levels
Even cassettes consume wall space, I am much better off digitally, these days I have zero physical media. (And a happier wife 
)
It’s OK for novelty but not the REEL thing 
2 Likes
I believe Thorens started out as a music box manufacturer, which is what I assume this thing is. Except every one I have seen plays cylinders, not disks, and they’re not easily interchangeable. What an interesting novelty!
Then there were player piano rolls.
2 Likes
I believe Matt the Techmoan, on his You Tube channel, reviewed a modern cylinder player kit. Search it up if interested.
1 Like
The Owl lives?! …
l love to sing-a
About the moon-a and the June-a and the spring-a…
1 Like
Here is a vintage playback system that may return, one day 
:
1 Like
The Phonautograph is for those who find the Edison Cylinder too bleeding edge 
It’s worth noting that those recordings were never meant to be played back, as it’s only possible to do that through optical means.
2 Likes
I personally prefer coax. But that’s just me 