FLAC Album Not Supported by Roon (ref#M3P4PE)

Hi! What’s not quite right with Roon?

· Music won’t play or issues with my library

Music won’t play or issues with my library

· Local files won't import or appear

Tell us what's going on

· I get the error message "audio stream format not supported" in the skipped files list for one 3-disc album in FLAC format. These files play just fine in VLC and other software. File names conform to conventional rules and do not differ from the rest of my library. I have tried re-encoding the files with DBPowerAmp and have forced a rescan. All to no avail. I suspect a codec problem, but have no way of finding out. Thanks for any advice you can provide.

Tell us about your home network

· Nokia router modem on fibre cable; 3 gigabit switches; 3 TP-link deco wireless mesh points. All working just fine.

What device is the Roon server running on? (MAC, PC, Nucleus, Intel Nuc with ROCK)

Please share a screenshot fro VLC, Tools → Media Information, Codec.

I have a nucleus rev A. The files are on an internal SSD card.

I will look into that. Right now, I don’t have access to my desk pc with VLC on it.
Thanks for pointing this out. At least then I’ll know what codec is being used. Will let you know.

@support,

Further information can be found here …

??? This is rather cryptic.

Hello @Leo_Reijnen,

We’re sorry you are having this problem.

Could you please upload one album or a few tracks to our "media storage so we could have a look at your track on our side and find if there is an issue with track itself ?

Thanks!

Regards.

It was just a note for Roon support so they are aware of your community topic … and can read what has already been discussed.

Do other FLAC files play? or are these the only FLAC files you have?

If you look at the webui for the Nucleus do you see any issue with missing codec?
It might looks something like this:

Here are some helpful KBs:

Hi @Leo_Reijnen,

We’ll be best equipped to diagnose what’s wrong if you’re able to provide our team with an affected FLAC file using the secure link @alex_h shared above. If you’ve already uploaded a track, can you please confirm the artist/track title so we can clarify that we’re inspecting the right media content?

In the meantime, for due diligence, do you notice any missing codecs in the RoonOS Web Admin page per @bearFNF’s comment above?

We’ll watch for your response. Thank you!

Hi Connor and everyone else weighing in here, it’s appreciated.

First the meantime questions: no, the RoonOS web admin page reports no errors or missing codecs. And yes, other local FLACs play just fine.

Unfortunately, I hit another snag in that my desktop PC had to go in for repair today, so I can’t send in one of the offending FLACs right now (I have do all this on my tablet) but as soon as it comes back I’ll follow this up! Please bear with me!

Oh, and by the way, I may already have the fmmpg file on my desktop as it is also used in my subtitling software. So I can probably just copy it over to Roon Data once my PC is back.

Hello @Leo_Reijnen,

Thanks for the update — no rush.

When you’re able to access your PC again, please upload one of the affected FLAC files using the link Alex provided and post a quick note here so we know it’s ready for review. That will let us inspect the file directly and see what’s preventing Roon from decoding it.

We’ll pick this up as soon as the sample is available.

Okay, PC up and running again. I successfully downloaded, unpacked and installed ffmpeg to the Codecs folder of my Nucleus and rebooted the Nucleus. Then forced a rescan. But no, it hadn’t helped one bit. Roon still doesn’t list the album in My Library and still says “audio stream format not supported”. So I have uploaded two tracks to the address you provided and am curious to hear what you may find.
I did load a file into VLC and looked at the codec info, but there was none. Actually, VLC didn’t display any info on the file except its path and name.

For what it’s worth, here’s the info I was able to extract from one of the files:

General
Complete name: M:\Pink Floyd(1975) Wish You Were Here 50\Disc 01\Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here 50 - CD1 - 02 - Welcome to the Machine.flac
Format: FLAC
Format/Info: Free Lossless Audio Codec
File size: 111 MiB
Duration: 7mn 30s
Overall bit rate mode: Variable
Overall bit rate: 2 073 Kbps
Album: Wish You Were Here 50
Album/Performer: Pink Floyd
Part: 1
Part/Total: 3
Track name: Welcome to the Machine
Track name/Position: 02
Track name/Total: 05
Performer: Pink Floyd
Composer: Roger Waters
Label: Legacy
Genre: Classic Rock
Recorded date: 1975
ISRC: GBN9Y1100086
Copyright: (P) 2025 Pink Floyd Music Limited
Cover: Yes
Cover type: Cover (front)
Cover MIME: image/jpeg
URL: https://music.amazon.com.au/albums/B0FPZBMVDZ?trackAsin=B0FQ12G2X4
ACOUSTID_FINGERPRINT: AQADtEmSREuSKIqSCT9u4NhzIJeNw8iPQxdyHIcPfEeOpMePi4fxMcczfPCJ48CBAznkIcXoD4eJPMdVqL_wETiODAcyHMABHwYOHwcOHz6OH4eLQ8eBC8fx48Jx4DhwHD8O6DseHHl2HDhyAzqc4_CJu9CH4wdwAjpwQAdO4DhwgAeAAwBwADgAAMcBAMcBAAAAHAKBAzp-IMfxHzmOBz4O4YeFAzhwHDwe_PghxO7hH–CH_7wB8d18PiR4zgEHMSh4ziH4AgOQAeOQziOIxcCHAcBHAABHsdx4kcO4MCPnDiMw29wHMeNQzwOH8eHH8ABHD9wHIcOQMdxHMIJ4AAOHbhwHDogHDx-5PjxH_mhA-lx8YAfED-Q44CO4zh04riRHzcO5PiPQziOQ_iR4wRwHseRKoBOwVJ6nDgBiieOqxB1fMfhPOh_nA–ogmNPjve49CO48QPXTiO7yCg4_jxBz8OQ8SBA8eh43hU3DgOHz70O_iREyb-4DjS6vhxHDgO4Dh4HAdwAAdw4DgOHMdx-DCQc9hxHCeRw8SNzrugHT5XAH6MD-Zx6Fh_HDkOHAao44B7fEjhH6eFczh8nMcF8TguwodJQjryw-pxnPBRSQpeCjWH7XBclIpm5D_OC90DRTk75BHxJXzgJwpQOcND1Dn4IzyDhpOgqgIv5F4mXDqYH-YD6vheBImUHyWzEMeeHz-OW_qEXEFyHo-iw2-D_R5-MPmCHtNmhFmU4jccPcavQLlw3kGfomHw7tgfqD2cTEc-wmO4HPkPXXmEL8jRTKRQH6FuNFRCrOWhP-CT4y166Idx6AJsHMd5bFZxXMGPw4cP_MCJ6xB8vDhOCAdu2IGP4_jxLMCxWcePwMd7nDp-NHXx5EiOHKeU45yN-7gu_Gj4IRklxsiTWWjCH_2M8mngGMyT4ch7A9qj49dwFP2RH-mL_yC87mAOnUG_wjq0bM5Bj_h2BKecozya4x6u40aY0CmSKcfn48fRG1cFPzhiNYKTJ9LQ50VPeIeNh7ij4zoO_7iErzhzHDne9PiODzl8HLpwHKh44ExR6PCPGz-MvDh-2EJw4vAFmRdO-BiH49B52Ph-fLCM2Dx-HC-M_GjCjcez5FCOHJd2PJSO-Qq-IxeSKD96jUvA18LF4AcTNToqE8kVC6EWBU_w5TiDdMwgL8EW6kOeoclTzH1wBRl1FeKzOMF5HE0TopSy4Mf1EFIsOHhz_PDB_ziOH_7xJwfv4sfh4zu-I_1u3MVB9aiEnTse49rx7vCu43nxB0-eEI8pvKglFk0qHfmVIzmcH88jXOg14RTC5NCR3wkcirPw42gu5eiVI-ZyJCbc4dRTHFf4oOKWoxnxCCc-hTnCHMp-9MJN4wcj-DtuPMZ1-MeNFyc2HS_0E7le_DhqnRyO98B5hFQaJEuO421Q6nCT5ehD_A9-Ybgm4-tQ5kejHPzS4DfyHJvDdMMfPD-qozljfMn8QPnRL46Q5jkOL9LQ5fiN8DGaGzrOi-jhDJ9wHMeV44O9BcdNF4Z0FT6OH96LDxK6I_p23Deu4xtKH8439CNxHfeFH_UUWBRFIbwoIflxH6YSfDngJzv2vdiViNBxZUtRncNxJoS54EMpB9dFXEobnHCmLBae58j3I-F3HH_gXzh3XK3waA12wwevJ-i5HQllRL8BBBUCkCCgrTcKKcEQRwABYxgAwiFRhlUAGWKcMNcqq6212iJmzRQWIAQscOaZZwQpiAqiqAXiGACUocSJI4151ltrrbXWXGAFJQYIQSoiBphSxBNUGCeAIsAIIpyAzCkqzLGKGnPFsc44cs2VVjinqHWMmQbMs4JrBpzFwjkjnDVKOmONs8o6K52ThhkhhAFSIWGQU0yIbbSiggDtmDCCUmOdAsYR4pBhDjlkmHCGCMKAFYIxLqxhijhmiLIOYGCEM846ZI2wUhgCBGbOaMsYsA4585yz1lpusRXWCQqQeMYKJRQCVBLhpHEKCQOQM9Q745RRGCmHkENKGgYMEYIIAKgCSiBAlGAOCeAQF8AgTAKBxAgEACBSKAGFI5ogRZRwzDFDgCCIeGQQIgJxhZgTVh1jDUNYK-OcMt45YYBySiIHEwKWEKeAUwC1wgwhyBDEkDBECHAEMBQgRqigCADjkCKAGAQIFgBSQpxTVhmkCSBSKKAEEEEoIwQJQRjlpHLGICeQMoIx5QxxRjgnzGUCAICgBdwqYgQULCFAHBMOCCAQEIAhQxhThkAGiJFQCKcAsgIAQJVThABBnKBOAUCUEMo8AAUCgCjBhIGKGBAAAAIoZcAwAgHCFAiAEAMMOAIICABCBABggBGKKUEVNgYIYgQlXjBgmQKQKSeIEEAqKIAwRBBHASNCAgKUEUBYCqRCiBitrDWPOCOEgosRZIQgSCEjHCAIGGcMsgAABoAxCgpDGWWCgEYAAEIINAEwhiAlNTACAAA
ACOUSTID_ID: d8b18681-bc77-4a50-a353-e8e9fcea1e90
ALBUMARTISTSORT: Pink Floyd
ALBUM_ARTISTS: Pink Floyd
ALBUM_ARTISTS_SORT: Pink Floyd
ALBUM_YEAR: 2025-12-12
ARTISTSORT: Pink Floyd
ARTISTS: Pink Floyd
ARTISTS_SORT: Pink Floyd
BARCODE: 196873561073
COMPOSERSORT: Waters, Roger
DISCSUBTITLE: Disc 1
INSTRUMENT: 12 string guitar; Hammond organ; Minimoog; acoustic guitar; analog synthesizer; cymbal; electric bass guitar; timpani
INVOLVEDPEOPLE: David Gilmour (12 string guitar); David Gilmour (acoustic guitar); David Gilmour (background vocals); David Gilmour (lead vocals); Nick Mason (cymbal); Nick Mason (timpani); Peter James (assistant engineer); Pink Floyd (producer); Richard Wright (analog synthesizer); Richard Wright (hammond organ); Richard Wright (minimoog); Roger Waters (analog synthesizer); Roger Waters (electric bass guitar)
IS_CLASSICAL: 0
COMPILATION: 0
IS_GREATEST_HITS: 0
IS_HD: 1
LYRICIST: Roger Waters
LYRICIST_SORT: Waters, Roger
MEDIA: Digital Media
MUSICBRAINZ_ORIGINALALBUMID: f4a8aa35-da90-33d8-9307-c630d38a2bed
MUSICBRAINZ_RELEASEGROUPID: 1a272023-10d3-38ee-bab3-317b55fcc21d
MUSICBRAINZ_ALBUMSTATUS: Official
MUSICBRAINZ_RELEASETRACKID: 98cfa1bb-6adf-4320-aae0-388b75dc96b6
MUSICBRAINZ_ALBUMTYPE: Album
MUSICBRAINZ_WORK: Welcome to the Machine
MUSICBRAINZ_RECORDING_WORK_ID: 0af0552f-cbe2-306b-a8cf-4f939df6eb67
MUSICBRAINZ_WORKID: 0af0552f-cbe2-306b-a8cf-4f939df6eb67
MUSICBRAINZ_RECORDING_WORK: Welcome to the Machine
ORIGINAL ALBUM: Wish You Were Here
ORIGINALRELEASEDATE: 1975-09-12
ORIGINAL YEAR: 1975-09-12
PART_TYPE: Song
PERFORMER_NAME: David Gilmour; Nick Mason; Richard Wright; Roger Waters
PERFORMER_NAME_SORT: Gilmour, David; Mason, Nick; Wright, Richard; Waters, Roger
PRODUCER: Pink Floyd
PRODUCER_SORT: Pink Floyd
RECORIDNG_ENGINEER: Brian Humphries
RECORDING_ENGINEER_SORT: Humphries, Brian
RECORDINGSTARTDATE: 1975-01
RECORDINGENDDATE: 1975-07
RECORDINGLOCATION: Abbey Road Studios
SCRIPT: Latin
SONGKONG_ID: 32400d51-3868-4794-8e44-ec395c02ae29
SINGLE_DISC_TRACK_NO: 02
WORK_TYPE: Song

Audio #0
Format: FLAC
Format/Info: Free Lossless Audio Codec
Duration: 7mn 30s
Bit rate mode: Variable
Bit rate: 2 061 Kbps
Channel(s): 2 channels
Sampling rate: 64.0 KHz
Bit depth: 24 bits
Stream size: 111 MiB (99%)
Writing library: libFLAC 1.5.0 (UTC 2025-02-11)
Language: English

Timecode of first frame :

Try and convert to a more common sampling rate (44.1 kHz, 48 kHz and power of 2 multiples thereof) instead.

PS: Roon also only supports integer bit depths of 16 bits, 24 bits and 32 bit.
No point in trying 18 bits or 20 bits because its “good enough” and /or “saves space”.

Okay, I will give that a try. Thanks!