Interesting choice of music one of my daily mixes [Investigating]

Roon Core Machine

Networking Gear & Setup Details

Connected Audio Devices

Number of Tracks in Library

Description of Issue

So, I’m skipping all the detail in my setup, but do let me know if that’s relevant.
Just now I put on one of my daily mixes, this one is called Lana del Rey. Felt like a nice relaxing choice for a relaxing evening.
And then I was surprised by The saw is family by Bone Gnawer… :smiley:
I do like a bit of metal, but this seems wildly out of place in this playlist? Particularly because it looks like the whole album “Feast of Flesh” is interspersed in the playlist?

Not an urgent issue, but I found it interesting, funny and odd, so I thought you might want to know…

Yep, seems something is up. I had a Blondie Mix that out of the 25 songs on the list nearly half (12) were from 3 albums not by Blondie. And, why is the Beatles Abbey Road taking up 20% of a Blondie Playlist

B-52s 5 tracks (4 from first album)
Bowie 4 tracks (3 from lets dance)
Beatles 7 tracks (5 from Abbey Road)

1 Like

Whilst the music choices for this Frank Sinatra list are more in keeping not sure 4 tracks in a row from A Kind of Blue work. Another part of Roon breaks. What is going at all with this app of late.

Phil Collins in a Cure mix it’s taking the piss!

3 Likes

Yeah, I noticed something similar. Didn’t take that screenshot, but there was also a section with 3 or 4 songs of the same Bone Gnawer album in a row. In that Lana Del Rey playlist…

If I’m not the only one seeing this weird behaviour then Roon really should look in to this.

Never had such a bad experience as last night.

I played a complete “electronic / dance’” remix album. After that Radio started with a complete unknown terrible Dutch track/artist with absolutely no relation to the played album.

1 Like


And again… “Bloodhunter” in a Tracy Chapman mix… really Roon? Does that make any sense?

This Rebecca Pidgeon mix hasn’t got a single Rebecca Pidgeon track:

What it has got is 18 (out of 25) Diana Krall tracks, one after the other:

There is something very broken here.

Actually that has happened since the beginning of Daily Mixes and I have sent examples over the months.

:woman_facepalming: :man_facepalming: perhaps the issues with Valance and Roon Radio have spawned these crazy lists.

1 Like

Same here.
Crazy choices in daily mix.
Classic in a Rock artist mix. Some mixes are completly filled with one artist, aso.
@Support when can we expect a solution?

As an example of one artist making the biggest part of the daily playlist.

Norah Jones playlist of today, total of 25 songs.

Norah Jones ; 5 out of 25 songs - 4 songs from the same album ‘Pick Me Of The Floor’

Melody Gardot : 10 songs out of 25 - 7 songs from the same album ‘Sunset in the Blue’

I can just as well play both the full albums, starting with Norah as that was the proposed ‘playlist

Album Artist Album Disc# Track# Title
Norah Jones Pick Me Up Off The Floor 1 9 Were You Watching?
Holly Cole Trio Don’t Smoke In Bed 1 1 I Can See Clearly Now
Melody Gardot My One and Only Thrill 1 6 Our Love Is Easy
Diana Krall The Girl in the Other Room 1 3 Temptation
Chet Baker Chet 1 1 Alone Together
Norah Jones Not Too Late 1 12 Rosie’s Lullaby
Eva Cassidy Live at Blues Alley 1 8 Fields of Gold
Norah Jones Pick Me Up Off The Floor 1 1 How I Weep
Norah Jones Pick Me Up Off The Floor 1 2 Flame Twin
Charles Lloyd & The Marvels I Long To See You 1 9 You Are So Beautiful
Melody Gardot My One and Only Thrill 1 1 Baby I’m a Fool
Melody Gardot Sunset in the Blue 1 2 C’est Magnifique
Melody Gardot Sunset in the Blue 1 6 Sunset in the Blue
Melody Gardot Sunset in the Blue 1 3 There Where He Lives in Me
Melody Gardot Live in Europe 1 1 Our Love Is Easy (Paris 2012)
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 8 Sway
Diana Krall The Girl in the Other Room 1 1 Stop This World
Diana Krall The Girl in the Other Room 1 2 The Girl in the Other Room
Melody Gardot Sunset in the Blue 1 5 You Won’t Forget Me
Diana Krall Wallflower (The Complete Sessions) 1 1 California Dreamin’
Melody Gardot Sunset in the Blue 1 1 If You Love Me
Melody Gardot Sunset in the Blue 1 9 From Paris with Love
Diana Krall Live In Paris 1 11 A Case Of You (Live)
Melody Gardot Sunset in the Blue 1 11 Moon River
Norah Jones Pick Me Up Off The Floor 1 4 Heartbroken, Day After

And now the really funny thing:
Today, I also have a Daily ‘Melody Gardot’ mix today - 25 songs.

Melody Gardot: 8 out of 25 songs - 5 songs from the same album ’ My One and Only Thrill’

Diana Krall: 13 out of 25 songs - 8 songs from the same album 'Turn Up the Quiet.

Album Artist Album Disc# Track# Title
Melody Gardot My One And Only Thrill (Special Edition) 2 4 My One And Only Thrill (Live In Paris)
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 6 Moonglow
Patricia Barber Clique 1 1 This Town
Cécile McLorin Salvant WomanChild 1 2 I Didn’t Know What Time It Was
Melody Gardot Worrisome Heart 1 7 One Day
Melody Gardot Sunset in the Blue 1 12 I Fall in Love Too Easily
Melody Gardot Sunset in the Blue 1 13 Little Something
Till Brönner Rio 1 7 High Night
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 1 Like Someone in Love
Diana Krall This Dream Of You 1 1 But Beautiful
Diana Krall Wallflower (The Complete Sessions) 1 1 California Dreamin’
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 2 Isn’t It Romantic
Diana Krall This Dream Of You 1 3 Autumn In New York
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 8 Sway
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 7 Blue Skies
Diana Krall Wallflower (The Complete Sessions) 1 3 Superstar
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 9 No Moon at All
Diana Krall Wallflower (The Complete Sessions) 1 2 Desperado
Diana Krall This Dream Of You 1 11 How Deep Is The Ocean
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 4 Night and Day
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 3 L-O-V-E
Melody Gardot My One And Only Thrill 1 15 My One And Only Thrill (Chill Out Mix)
Melody Gardot My One and Only Thrill 1 10 Deep Within the Corners of My Mind
Melody Gardot My One and Only Thrill 1 1 Baby I’m a Fool
Melody Gardot My One And Only Thrill (Special Edition) 2 5 Love Me Like A River Does (Live In Paris)

Yeah, Roon, this is getting crazy and needs attention.

So ok, I do have an eclectic tase in music. But seriously, bloody Bloodhunter (punt intended) again? In a Patti Smith playlist?
And “Dark Elite”??? My Roon playlist generator has established a weird fetish for all sorts of metal, some of which I enjoy, but NOT IN A PATTY SMITH PLAYLIST!

Also, who are “Corazones Estrangulados”, it’s not death metal, but I also don’t see the link with Patti Smith?

And look at this, a bit further down the playlist… Half of the songs have no relation at all with Patti Smith.

Can you please, pretty please, look in to this?

Hi All,

Thanks for writing in and bringing this to our attention. We are investigating things further and will follow up with more information as soon as possible.

Thanks for your patience in the meantime! :+1:

And there are a few obscure artist, I never heard about and completely unrelated to the mix seed, that shows up in at least one mix per day. Like “Mario Abbate”. I saw the same song from him in the last few days in different mixes.

Well, the story gets funnier everytime. This time Diana Krall is taking over from Melody Gardot.
Today I got a new Norah Jones daily mix (25 albums as usual )

Norah Jones ; 5 out of 25 songs - ( 4 albums which is fine)
Melody Gardot : 16 songs out of 25 ( 7 albums )

Album Artist Album Disc# Track# Title
Norah Jones Day Breaks 1 11 Carry On
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 2 Isn’t It Romantic
Eva Cassidy Live at Blues Alley 1 9 Autumn Leaves
Melody Gardot Sunset in the Blue 1 5 You Won’t Forget Me
Norah Jones Day Breaks 1 6 Don’t Be Denied
Norah Jones Come Away with Me 1 14 The Nearness of You
Norah Jones The Fall 1 2 Even Though
Norah Jones Pick Me Up Off The Floor 1 5 Say No More
Diana Krall Live In Paris 1 11 A Case Of You (Live)
Diana Krall Live In Paris 1 6 I’ve Got You Under My Skin (Live)
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 8 Sway
Diana Krall Wallflower (The Complete Sessions) 1 1 California Dreamin’
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 9 No Moon at All
Diana Krall The Look Of Love 1 5 Besame Mucho
Diana Krall The Girl in the Other Room 1 3 Temptation
Melody Gardot Sunset in the Blue 1 1 If You Love Me
Diana Krall The Girl in the Other Room 1 1 Stop This World
Diana Krall The Girl in the Other Room 1 4 Almost Blue
Diana Krall The Girl in the Other Room 1 2 The Girl in the Other Room
Diana Krall Live In Paris 1 1 I Love Being Here With You (Live)
Diana Krall Live In Paris 1 2 Let’s Fall In Love (Live)
Diana Krall Turn Up the Quiet 1 1 Like Someone in Love
Melody Gardot Sunset in the Blue 1 11 Moon River
Diana Krall The Very Best of Diana Krall 1 1 'S Wonderful
Diana Krall The Very Best of Diana Krall 1 7 The Look of Love

I share some of these same oddities - I just had Bloodhunter in a Katie Melua mix, as well as the Corazones Estrangulados you mention. There’s definitely weirdness afoot in the playlists of late.

You haven’t heard Bone Gnawer yet? You’re missing out! :rofl:
A few days ago I had another playlist “Annie Lennox” with 6 or 8 Bone Gnawer songs in a row… (Neglected to take a screenshot… Sorry.) So yeah, definitely an issue. Sounds like Roon is looking in to it, hope they can fix it soon!

2 Likes

Roon Daily Mixes are totally f’ed up now. I don’t want to hear Bone Gnawer. What garbage. The other side of the coin, I get a lot of the same music over and over in almost every Roon Daily Mix, regardless of the title. I have almost totally reverted to playing just albums.

EDIT: I’ve been with Roon for over 4 years. Until now, Daily Mixes and Roon Radio have always worked well for me. Now, they have become a mess. A lot seems to be since the integration with KKBOX. I don’t want foreign language music and I don’t want metal. My metal days are behind me. I like the Eagles, but not multiple tracks in every Daily Mix and every other Roon Radio selection, over and over again.

Is anyone at Roon responsible for these functions?

EDIT2: Just to emphasize, Roon Daily Mixes are really messed up. Mine are full of foreign language music and scattered with horrible metal. This just started within the past week or two, I think.

EDIT3: Daily Mixes are now unusable for me. They are peppered with unlistenable garbage tracks.

2 Likes

Could be worse. You might get Diana Krall…

1 Like

I love Diana Krall.

3 Likes