Search by Composer - Album Display


(David Litot) #1

It would be very useful to be able to sort by album when performing a search for instance by Composer !


(Ludwig van Marbach) #2

Can you clarify. You can already browse by composer and sort by album title at the same time.

What precisely are you trying to do, from what screen?


(David Litot) #3

Hello,

I’m looking by composer and when I select one in the liste I see all his tracks without any useful sorting. I then try to group by album but there is not such option…

When there is many tracks and albums forms composer it is very useful to look at it by album

Thanks in advance for your help

Regards


#4

Hi David,

Once you have selected a composer, Roon displays a list of works.

If you then click on a particular work, Roon then displays the albums that contain it.

Does this help?


(David Litot) #5

Not really, sorry !

For instance when I click Back I have more than 20 albums and I don’t want to see the tracks but spot in the albums !

David


#6

Ok, seems you’re not interest in the works per se, just the albums … Try this:

Album Browser
Focus
Composers, search Bach and select.

This will then restrict the display of albums to only those that referance Bach.


(David Litot) #7

Hi agzin,

This trick will work, it still it would be very handy to be able to group by album from the composer bpview. Let me know if you plan to add that feature (it is one I’ve been using for year with competition package)
Also noticed that your search does not work to good

Thanks again

David Litot


(Ludwig van Marbach) #8

I think what you want is a link from the Composer page to the Album browser with a focus on that composer.


(Andrew Cox) #9

People often feel that way when a Bach search throws up PDQ Bach intermingled with JS Bach …

But more seriously, what are the problems with search and what would you prefer to see ?


(David Litot) #10

Hello,
This could do it ! At the very end the less number of clicks to get something the better. Another way would be to show the albums spot in the selected composer page !

Regards


(Ludwig van Marbach) #11

And I’d second the request. Could be very useful. @mike @brian


(David Litot) #12

Searching by composer does not display albums in the results but only tracks. This is very annoying because there is no easy way to see for instance all Beethoven albums !


#13

David, I’ve moved this into your exiting topic.


(David Litot) #14

Hello. Any progress on this feature ? Painful to use roon for classical music !


(Brad McHose) #15

I just signed up for Roon today to try it out for my dad. I’m using a brand new MacBook Pro with fully updated software, and I just downloaded Roon a few hours ago, so presumably everything is up to date.

At the moment I’m just working off of my Tidal subscription and I’m playing the music from my laptop just to focus on Roon itself. I’ll hook things up to my stereo later. (Parasound and PSB Synchrony Ones in case anyone’s interested)

I can’t find a way to organize classical albums by the composers’ last names. I can get a list of composers organized by their last names (seemingly all composers?), but I want a list of classical albums–specifically, the classical albums that I’ve favorited on Tidal (or in the future the classical albums that I’ve downloaded and/or favorited on Roon).

I poked around and found an old thread about this in which the conclusion was that it can’t be done, and I didn’t find anything newer that answered my question (after making a fairly modest search effort).

Is there a way to organize classical albums by composer? (It seems not, since if I have a list albums the drop down list of options for organizing them doesn’t include composers as an option. But I hope I’m wrong! )

Thanks.

Brad


(Andrew Cox) #16

Hi Brad,

I’ve shifted your post into this Feature Request because Roon cannot currently sort Album by Composer and it remains a feature request.

You can sort Classical albums using Albums/Focus/Genre/Classical and make a Bookmark to recall that view with a click. You can also click that Focus from + to - in order to view all Albums that are not Classical.

Within that Classical focus you can sort by Artist, but, as I’m sure you will agree, that is not the same as sorting by Composer.

You can also view your Roon library by Composer, but that is Work based, which is not always what you want.

I would still very much support a Sort by Composer view in Albums, Tracks, Genres etc. so lets hope that this Feature Request gets sufficient support to become a thing !


Classical Albums by composer
(Brad McHose) #17

Hi Andrew,

Thanks for replying. The best option at this point seems to be to focus your albums on classical and then sort them by album title. That way you’re good to go for all of the albums that put the composer’s last name as the first part of the album title, which is a decent percentage of classical albums. Not perfect, but it prevents the problem from being a deal-breaker (for me anyway).

It’s still puzzling why sorting albums by composer isn’t an option …

Brad


(Daniel Beyer) #18

I wanted to third Ludwig’s request.


(Malcolm Inman) #19

And me. If I restrict Albums to say Beethoven I get 300 odd albums - I can’t read all the titles (not visible) so have to go through 1 by 1 looking for Symphony No 2 and the artist I want. It won’t allow me to restrict to Beethoven and 2 or Beethoven and Symphony - says try removing some Focus criteria. How nice to select on a Composer and see all the Albums rather than a 100 “1 Allegro” all from different albums.


(Kevin White) #20

I agree. For example, I have the complete Beethoven string quartets by two different quartets and it seems impossible to organise them so I am playing the right movements for each quartet in the right order. I am on a trial period with Roon and if I can’t work out a better way of managing my classical music (about 50% of my listening) it feels like this will be a deal breaker.