Hi, I’m using Roon v1.6 (build 401) with HQplayer and mostly using Tidal Hifi. I’m also have problem with MQA.
Mostly, Roon plays Flac format whether media is MQA or not. But sometimes Roon plays MQA format. It is completely not logical. I’ve tried everything, but Roon didn’t play MQA properly. Nearly all time, I see this signal path for source and output (On hqplayer side I’m using DSD upstream mostly):
So, is this a known bug? What can I do to handle this?
If you play the MQA file to a different endpoint that is not HQPlayer, is it identified as MQA? Does this same issue happen across multiple types of MQA files or just specific ones? Does local MQA files exhibit the same behavior for the HQPlayer zone? If you don’t have any local MQA files, you can download a few off the 2L Test Bench: http://www.2l.no/hires/index.html
But using with Tidal, most of my collection is consist of well known jazz recordings and nearly all of them have MQA version also. I have a Tidal Hifi subscription. I think this screenshot shows the current situation:
Works for me. I would say your not actually playing the mqa version. In the versions tab check which is currently active. How did you start playback? Did you press play from the album page as shown in your post?
I too have been able to play the MQA version properly from TIDAL. Since local MQA content works as expected, this behavior looks like it’s limited to TIDAL streaming MQA content only. Can you let me know if this occurs on other endpoints as well?
Assuming this is not a case of Tidal regional licensing issue that prevents you from hearing certain albums in MQA, your Roon configuration got the wrong 16-bit non-MQA version from Tidal as shown in the signal path. All Tidal MQA streams are 24-bit, as shown in CrystalGipsy’s signal path.